Tuttle has sent many wrestlers on to the next level of college wrestling. Many of those wrestlers became college All-Americans for their respected colleges.

Next Level Tigers

  • Ryan Martin

    University of Central Oklahoma

    1989-1994

    134

    2X NCAA D2 All-American (5th, 1st)

    1X NCAA D2 National Champion 1994

  • Trent London

    University of Nebraska

    1990-1991

    Garden City Community College

    1991-1993

    126

    2X NJCAA All-American

    1993 NJCAA National Champion - 126

  • Steven Schmidt

    Oklahoma State University

    1994-1998

    134, 142

    3X NCAA D1 All-American (4th, 2nd, 7th)

    NCAA D1 National Runner-up

  • Jeff Henning

    University of Oklahoma

    1998-2000

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2001-2003

    184

    2X NCAA D2 All-American (3rd, 3rd)

  • Jared Henning

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2002-2007

    125, 133

    2X NCAA D2 All-American (7th, 2nd)

  • BJ Jackson

    Oklahoma State

    2003-2006

    149

  • Brandon Benson

    Army West Pointe

    2004-2006

    Oklahoma City University

    2006-2008

    157

    2X NAIA All-American (4th, 6th)

  • Ryan Henning

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2004-2007

    141

    McKendree University

    2007-2008

    141

  • Josh Bryant

    McKendree University

    2006-2010

    174

    3X NAIA All-American (4th, 3rd, 6th)

  • Bobby Williams

    University of Oklahoma

    2009-2010

    Ouachita Baptist University

    2010-2014

    157

    2X NCAA D2 All-American (5th, 7th)

  • Shane Woods

    University of Wyoming

    2010-2015

    184, 197

    3x NCAA D1 Nationals Qualifier

  • Cole Gracey

    Army West Pointe

    2011-2015

    165

    2X NCAA D1 Nationals Qualifier

    U.S. Army Officer (2015–2025)

  • Dylan Coppenbarger

    Baker University

    2011-2013

    157/165

  • Zach Beard

    University of Wyoming

    2013-2014

    165

  • Gunner Lafoon

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2013-2014

    Otero College

    2015-2017

    125/133

    2017 NJCAA All-American (5th)

  • Riley Fielder

    Oklahoma City University

    2014-2018

    197

  • Dakota Head

    Ouachita Baptist University

    2014-2015

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2015-2017

    157/165

  • Blake Dauphin

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2015-2018

    133

  • Dustin Mason

    Bethany College

    2015-2020

    197/285

    NAIA Qualifier 2019

  • Blake Berryhill

    Northeaster Oklahoma A&M

    2016-2017 (Football)

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2017-2019 (Wrestling)

    285

  • Dayton Garrett

    West Virginia University

    2016-2017

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2017-2021

    157/165

  • Beau Guffey

    Army West Pointe

    2017-2021

    149, 157,165

    2020 LTG Hal Moore Warrior Athlete of Excellence Award

    U.S. Army Officer (2021-2026)

  • Brik Filippo

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2017-2023

    149

    2X NCAA D2 All-American (5th, 6th)

  • Noah McQuigg

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2017-2021

    125/133

  • Tanner Johnson

    Air Force Academy

    2017-2021

    174

    2021 Academic All BIG 12

    Commission: Space Operations, Vandenburg AFB, CA

  • Trey Mason

    Bethany College

    2018-2022

    NAIA National Qualifier

  • Rhett Golowenski

    Appalachian State University

    2018-2019

    Oklahoma State University

    2019-2021

    125

  • Carson Berryhill

    University of Oklahoma

    2019-2024

    184

  • Logan Farrell

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2019-2021

    133

  • Brady Dearmond

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2020-2024

    157

  • Dustin Plott

    Oklahoma State University

    2020-2025

    174/184

    4X NCAA D1 All-American

    (6th, 6th, 2nd. 4th)

    2X BIG 12 Champion

    4X BIG 12 Finalist

    3X NWCA Scholar All-American

  • Garrett Steidley

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2020-2025

    125

  • Gage Shetley

    Northeastern Oklahoma A&M

    2020-2022

    Emmanuel University

    2023-2025

    157

    NJCAA All-American (6th)

    2X Scholar All-American

  • Dalton Burdick

    Northeastern Oklahoma A&M

    2020-2023

    141

    NJCAA National Qualifier

    NJCAA Scholar All-American

  • Ryder Ramsey

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2021-2024

    141

  • Luke Surber

    Oklahoma State University

    2021-2025

    197/285

    3X NCAA D1 Nationals Qualifier

    4X NWCA Scholar All-American

  • Bryce Dauphin

    University of Wyoming

    2021-2023

    149/157

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2023-2026

    165

  • Harley Andrews

    University of Nebraska

    2022-2027

    285

  • Reece Davis

    University of Nebraska

    2022-2023

    Oklahoma City University

    2023-2026

    149

  • Hayden Brown

    Oklahoma City University

    2022-2026

    157/165

    2X NAIA National Qualifier

    SAC 157  Runner Up (2024-25)

    SAC 165  Champion (2026)

  • Jack Golowenski

    Colorado School of Mines

    2022-2023

    Ouachita Baptist University

    2023-2026

    157

    2024-2025 NWCA Scholar All-America Team

  • Braden Potts

    Oklahoma City University

    2023-2024

    125

  • Sam Schmidt

    Ouachita Baptist University

    2023-Present

    165

    2X NWCA Scholar All-America Team

    3X MIAA Academic Honor Roll

  • Tucker Waitman

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2023-Present

    165

  • Jaxon Koeltzow

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2023-Present

    141

  • Beau Hickman

    Oklahoma State

    2025-Present

    149

  • Chance Fisher

    University of Central Oklahoma

    2026-Present

    133